Skip to main content

Experimental Philosophy Trilogy

Created in a deadpan presentational style reminiscent of Coonley's faux-instructional Pony videos, the Experimental Philosophy Trilogy fuses a farrago of materials appropriated from stock media archives, chroma-key mischief, and simulated audience polls to illustrate recent findings from the burgeoning field of experimental philosophy, or "x-phi." This controversial young discipline, which takes a burning armchair as its emblem, supplants traditional ways of conducting philosophy with empirical research methods borrowed from psychology and the social sciences.

Narrated by non-philosophers for a non-expert audience, the three videos in this collection introduce seminal x-phi studies on the subjects of intentional behavior (The Side-Effect Effect), the asynchronous way in which people interpret others' happiness and unhappiness (Happinessness), and folk understandings of moral relativity (Absolute Folk). The videos have been used to spark vigorous online arguments and real-life conversations about the way philosophical values play into our understanding of everyday experience (and vice versa).

# Title Artists Run Time Year Country
1 Experimental Philosophy Trilogy Part 1: The Side-Effect Effect Ben Coonley 00:02:49 2009 United States
2 Experimental Philosophy Trilogy Part 2: Happinessness Ben Coonley 00:04:02 2012 United States
3 Experimental Philosophy Trilogy Part 3: Absolute Folk Ben Coonley 00:07:20 2013 United States

Experimental Philosophy Trilogy Part 1: The Side-Effect Effect

Ben Coonley
2009 | 00:02:49 | United States | English | Color | Stereo | 4:3 | DV video

DESCRIPTION

An ordinary living room with a green screen, TV, and domestic cat serves as the backdrop for this DIY introduction to experimental philosophy. The president of a company is considering a vice president's moneymaking scheme. He says, "Look, I know this program will harm the environment, but I don't care at all about that. All I care about is maximizing profits. So let's start the program." The company adopts the policy, and sure enough, the environment is harmed. Now consider a seemingly straightforward question: Did the chairman of the board harm the environment intentionally?

 Comedian Eugene Mirman narrates this dramatization of an influential study by experimental philosopher Joshua Knobe titled "Intentional Action and Side-Effects in Ordinary Language" AKA "the side-effect effect."

This work is also available as part of the Experimental Philosophy Trilogy.

Experimental Philosophy Trilogy Part 2: Happinessness

Ben Coonley
2012 | 00:04:02 | United States | English | Color | Stereo | 16:9 | HD video

DESCRIPTION

Is Miley more or less happy than June Cleaver? Given very fragmentary information about the lives of two stereotypical figures with identical emotional states, people tend to give strangely asymmetrical evaluations of the two characters' propensity for happiness and unhappiness. An illustration of a controversial study called "The Ordinary Concept of Happiness (and Others Like It)".

This work is also available on the Experimental Philosophy Trilogy.

Experimental Philosophy Trilogy Part 3: Absolute Folk

Ben Coonley
2013 | 00:07:20 | United States | English | Color | Stereo | 16:9 | HD video

DESCRIPTION

An intrepid academic travels the world, asking people if it is OK for someone to stab a friend in order to test the sharpness of a knife. If one person says it's OK and another says it's not OK, can both respondents be right? This video is an illustration of a multi-layered experiment designed to test the claims of several traditional philosophers that non-experts (folk) tend to hold rigidly absolutist views of morality. 3D video is used to create harmonious illusions of depth as well asynchronous left and right eye views—a fitting visual analogy for the complexity and mutability of folk moral relativism. Singer Amanda Palmer's disembodied head narrates.

This title is also available on Experimental Philosophy Trilogy.